Dr. John Ashdown-Hill talks about his research regarding King Richard III
Today we have a special guest to present to you,
Dr. John Ashdown-Hill,
historian and member of the Royal Historical Society, the Society of Genealogists, the Richard III Society and the Centre Européen d’Etudes Bourguignonnes. He has kindly agreed to let us interview him for the “King Richard III-Week”.
Dr. Ashdown-Hill has done extensive research over the years and has published his results in diverse essential articles and books about the Ricardian era. It is an honour for us, with our newly established KingRichardArmitage website, to have Dr. Ashdown-Hill telling us about his work and research efforts regarding King Richard III.
Latest Publications:
“The Last Days of Richard III”
“Eleanor, the Secret Queen”
“Richard III’s ‘Beloved Cousyn’”
(Click on the links to find more details about the books.)
Dr. Ashdown-Hill has kindly agreed to answer some questions about his research work:
What in your opinion is the key aspect of King Richard III’s reign and his legitimacy as king of England?
To my mind the first key area to be investigated is Edward IV’s marriage – because Richard III’s right to the throne depends upon the claim that Edward IV was married to Eleanor Talbot, not Elizabeth Woodville. I remember deciding to read up on Eleanor at an early stage of my interest in Richard III – some 15 years ago. I was totally amazed to find that nothing substantial had been written about her and that no real research had then been done on her. This was the reason for my work on her, which lead to a number of Ricardian articles and to my book, Eleanor, the Secret Queen. I see no reason to doubt that Eleanor was the victim of Edward IV’s libido, or that he contracted a secret marriage with her for his own selfish ends. Thus to my mind Richard III’s claim to the throne was entirely genuine, and probably took Richard himself completely by surprise. I am still researching Eleanor Talbot and hope to publish new evidence of her relationship with Edward IV in my forthcoming planned study of that king and his love-life. I also still hope to clarify further the identity of the human remains from the Whitefriars in Norwich which may well be Eleanor’s.
What did previous researchers overlook or do wrong in their approach to King Richard III?
I am amazed at how repetitive the writing about Richard III has been and is. My latest book was a deliberate reaction against this. I think it is a waste of time to keep writing about ‘who murdered the Princes in the Tower’. They weren’t ‘Princes’ anyway (so I will not use this term except in inverted commas), and no proof exists that they were murdered at all, so why should we be so preoccupied with ‘who did it’? Better to try for a balanced account of Richard himself. Thus The Last Days of Richard III is kinder to Henry VII than are the writings of most Ricardian authors, but also tries to focus on exactly WHAT RICHARD DID rather than on WAS RICHARD GOOD OR BAD. As a result we discover that during the last six months of his life Richard III was actively planning for the future. He expected to defeat Henry Tudor and to go on being king!
What is your unique approach to research on King Richard III and his time?
One of my most important and original contributions has been my work on Richard III’s DNA. This arose out of the need to identify some remains in Belgium which were thought to be those of Richard’s sister, Margaret of York. As a historian and a writer I try always to be clear about what the evidence shows, and about what we know or don’t know. When we DON’T KNOW, but have to draw our own conclusions I try to tell my readers that this is what I am doing, and to explain where I am coming from. Too many historians, past and present, have misleadingly pretended to KNOW things which are really only their personal opinion, and to my mind this is not honest.
For example, some earlier writers claimed (wrongly) that Eleanor Talbot was not the daughter of the first earl of Shrewsbury. Also many writers have dismissed out of hand the notion of Eleanor Talbot’s marriage to Edward IV – though the nineteenth-century historian Gairdner, who was not a particular friend of Richard III, stated very clearly that there was no reason to doubt the Talbot marriage.
We must keep a balance here. Because the mistakes have not all been made by Richard III’s enemies! Richard’s friends have also sometimes presented as FACTS ideas which are really nothing more than speculation. For example the story that Richard III attended his last mass at Sutton Cheney has no historical basis whatever, and is almost certainly untrue.
I think that all historians bear a great responsibility. First, they should try to get at the facts; second they should say frankly when they are speculating, and third, they should be honest about their own prejudices.
Thank you, Dr. Ashdown-Hill, for such deep insights into your work.
It was a real pleasure to have such a knowledgeable researcher about the time and life of King Richard III to interview.
I hope you have enjoyed the background information about the central question of King Richard III’s reign and legitimacy.
Countdown
King Richard Week
begins here on Monday, the 22nd of August, 2011
Only till Monday, 22nd of August, 2011 midnight our donor pays for every made signature.
So please hurry and bring your interested contacts in to sign! (No use of force please ;o)
Final ‘royal’ treat before the big event:
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Petition & Donation
Please don’t forget the KingRichardArmitage-Petition with donation for signatures till the 22nd of August. (Our current donation amount is:
€ 13,20)
No donation from you required, just spread the word about the petition and bring in signatures. Each single one till the 22nd of August 2011 counts to make our donor pay !
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
The Countdown Begins
King Richard Week
begins here on Monday, 22nd of August, 2011
Today’s ‘royal’ treat:
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Petition & Donation
Please don’t forget the KingRichardArmitage-Petition with donation for signatures till the 22nd of August. (Our current donation amount is:
€ 11,50)
No donation from you required, just spread the word about the petition and bring in signatures. Each single one till the 22nd of August 2011 counts to make our donor pay !
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Your Royal Treat for Today
King Richard Week
will start here on Monday, 22nd of August, 2011
For all participants and visitors of the Battle of Bosworth re-enactment, enjoy the event and have a great time!!!
Your ‘royal’ treat for today:
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Petition & Donation
Please don’t forget the KingRichardArmitage-Petition with donation for signatures till the 22nd of August. (Our current donation amount is:
€ 11,30)
No donation from you required, just spread the word about the petition and bring in signatures. Each single one till the 22nd of August 2011 counts to make our donor pay !
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Your Royal Treat
King Richard Week
will start here on Monday, 22nd of August, 2011
The Battle of Bosworth re-enactment
is held this weekend, 20th – 21st of August, 2011
(More details regarding the event here.)
Your ‘royal’ treat for today:
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Petition for the film “Richard III”
Please don’t forget to sign the KingRichardArmitage-Petition.
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
King Richard Week – Reminder
King Richard Week
with interviews, presentations, articles, videos, …
will start here and on participating blogs
on Monday, 22nd of August, 2011!
Don’t miss this singular Richard-Event!
A podcast about King Richard III, evaluating his time as King of England
by RexFactor (dated 27th of July, 2011) with the message:
“Don’t read Shakespeare, listen to RexFactor.”
Today’s ‘royal’ treat:
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Petition & Donation
Please don’t forget the KingRichardArmitage-Petition with donation for signatures till the 22nd of August. (Our current donation amount is:
€ 10,60)
No donation from you required, just spread the word about the petition and bring in signatures. Each single one till the 22nd of August 2011 counts to make our donor pay !
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Reminder for King Richard Week (22nd – 28th of August 2011)
King Richard Week
will start here on Monday, 22nd of August, 2011
Today’s ‘royal’ treat:
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Petition & Donation
Please don’t forget the KingRichardArmitage-Petition with donation for signatures till the 22nd of August. (Our current donation amount is:
€ 10,30)
No donation from you required, just spread the word about the petition and bring in signatures. Each single one till the 22nd of August 2011 counts to make our donor pay !
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Announcement of King Richard Week & Battle of Bosworth Re-Enactment
King Richard Week
starts here on Monday, 22nd of August, 2011
Battle of Bosworth Re-Enactment
The memorable Battle of Bosworth, where King Richard III died, is commemorated in a re-enactment held at the Bosworth Battlefield Heritage Centre the coming weekend (20th – 22nd of August, 2011).
More details about the festivities can be found here.
The Richard III Foundation, Inc., engaged supporter of our petition and presented in more detail here at our website, will organise part of the festivities at the Battle of Bosworth re-enactment and has “something special planned” for the event!
I am quite curious, what that can be…
If you are in the region and can join the festivities, take part and support the army of our King Richard III!
(Press Release “Redeeming A King” for download here.)
Today’s ‘royal’ treats:
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Petition & Donation
Please don’t forget the KingRichardArmitage-Petition with donation for signatures till the 22nd of August. (Our current donation amount is: € 8,80)
No donation from you required, just spread the word about the petition and bring in signatures. Each single one till the 22nd of August 2011 counts to make our donor pay !
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Invitation to the “King Richard Week”
Among the fans it is now an open secret, that Richard Armitage has a big day this year.
The day I speak of is the
22nd of August
Wonderful things and presents are in preparation and on their way and I know a lot of you have planned something special for the day itself.
I for one will try to find a cinema playing “Captain America” in English here (and it is clear to all of you that I don’t do it to see Captain America, no, it is for only 8 special minutes of the film.)
To celebrate Mr. Armitage here on this site, we, the administrators, came together with some wonderful and very special RA-ladies (names and participators will be revealed later) and have planned a
King Richard Week
from 22nd – 28th of August, 2011.
for this king:
or rather this king?
Please join us in the celebrations and revel in lots of lovely information, research, interviews and celebration around Mr. Armitage and his project King Richard III.
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *
Petition & Donation
Please don’t forget the KingRichardArmitage-Petition with donation for signatures till the 22nd of August. (Our current donation amount is: € 7,20)
No donation from you required, just spread the word about the petition and bring in signatures. Each single one till the 22nd of August 2011 counts to make our donor pay !
* . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . * . *